Bachelor Jason Mesnick spoiler alert!

How can this be the spoiler when they have only aired one show? Well, I went to the FORT (fans of reality TV) where they almost always call the correct winner. It is not just the usual rumors of a “friend of a friend of a friend who knows” or “I saw Jason and so and so on a secret date” thing.

The fort analyzers of this show do screencap analysis. By the way, these FORT’ers are very serious and take pride in what they do. I went there and saw who they think it is with back up pictures to support their analysis. This for me is like knowing what my presents are underneath the Christmas tree without having to wait for that day.

In the past, my wife and I would watch these shows and give our top 3 guesses of who we thought would make it to the final 3. We usually do well and get 2 right from the first episode. The 3 I would have thought would make it to the final 3 are Melissa, Shannon, and Stephanie based on Jason’s interactions with them. At the end of the first show, when they previewed DeAnna Pappas in an upcoming episode, I thought hmmm, there is a chance he picks her.

I think in the Bachelor Byron series, he ends up picking a former bachelorette Mary who didn’t make it to the final rose ceremony with Bachelor Bob.

Well back to the spoiler thing, someone at the fort published photo screen caps of the proposal. This shows Jason holding the final rose ceremony winners hand with a ring on it. Apparently there are unique “moles” on it that match up with Melissa the former Dallas Cowboy Cheerleader. It is amazing what some of these analyzers are able to do with screencaps.

molecomparison-highdef

melissadallascowboys-molezoom

They even put the arrows on there for you to show you which moles. These are shrunk down from the originals I saw from the actual site. Now, I personally did not look at pictures of every girl’s arms, but these serious TV watchers obviously did. I guess we will see at the end of the season if this is a true spoiler. I am guessing this FORT person is right.

Bachelor Jason Mesnick and Melissa spoilers confirmed

Watch the latest videos on YouTube.com

33 Comments

Subscribe to the Comments

Mary, January 19, 2009:

The person he picks is wearing a light blue dress, as shown in the clips.
When she says “Oh my gosh!” as he propses it really sounds like Melissa!
Yay!
Diana, January 31, 2009:

I wish it was Melissa but I dont think so. In upcoming previews they go to Seattle, its cold there,in another preview,three women strp off the pier in short sleeves,one is Stephanie wearing her white fur vest, one is Jillian,the other I fear is Molly, hope I am wrong.There is a clip with Jason jumping off the boat with Stephanie, I assume its her cause she has white bottoms to her suit, Melissas are striped so I dont know where the episode comes about with Melissa on the boat with Jason as the previews showed, once again,hope I am wrong lol
Renae, February 3, 2009:

It’s true. He does pick Melissa. I analyzed screen caps too. She always wears a ring on her right pinky finger, and the woman he chooses has that same ring on the same finger.
Alicia, February 9, 2009:

Its Melissa because on the frame before this one, it showed Jason getting on his knee, and not only did she wear a blue dress, she has a gold pinky ring. And Melissa is the only one that wears a gold pinky ring during the whole show.
Jenna, February 10, 2009:

Have you guys ever seen Melissa wear pale colors or have french fingernails???? NO!!! She is always in dark colors and dark nail polish. Molly is the lighter one:)
Catherine, February 14, 2009:

Melissa’s nails are french manicured the same way throughout the whole season. It’s DEFINATELY her! She always ends up on Jason’s lap and they always sit closer together than anyone of the other girls. My pick is that its Melissa and Jillian that are the final two. But Jason and Jillian’s connection is nothing near him and Melissa’s. They’re absolutely perfect for each other!
Kelly, February 15, 2009:

Melissa’s nails are ALWAYS French manicured. and she does wear pale colors sometimes, like when they went to the set of general hospital, she was in white, that’s as pale as you can go.
Hayli, February 16, 2009:

i knooooow it is melissa! not only do all of these things match up PERFECTLY.. but also, i can always always always pick the winner from the very first episode. it is so weird.. but i am never wrong. and guess who i pick the first episod.. MELISSA!!

p.s. i used to watch the dallas cowboy cheerleaders show.. and i remember melissa on it. she was my favorite.. even then, such a sweet girl!
Diana, February 16, 2009:

If you notice in the propsal scene the ring is not there when she raises her right hand the second time but hope you are right, I hope he choosed Melissa….
Erin, February 19, 2009:

He chooses Melissa and then ABC had him play out this whole after thing and he dumps Mel and chooses Molly. It’s on some reality steve website
Denise, February 23, 2009:

I know for a fact it is Melissa. They have been seen together in Kirkland, Wa. where Jason lives.
Holly, February 24, 2009:

That definitely points out to be Melissa, as I had hoped from episode one. But something you gotta realize… Would ABC really make it THAT easy to figure out from the beginning? I mean, the moles, the pinky ring… even as the camera shoots them after the proposal and he is swinging her around, you can tell it’s a brunette… so is there some twist? There has to be. I’m not saying that’s not Melissa in those shots, because it definitely seems to be her, but I am saying that’s not the end of it. He may realize he shouldn’t have let one of the others go AFTER he proposes… which is why the DRAMATIC “After the Final Rose Ceremony” is without audience and kept intimate due to the emotions of the parties involved. Like maybe, Melissa’s heart ends up broken on the set. I’m not sure, but I am skeptical with how easy they made it to figure out who he chose, and why it has to be so private in the end. I am keeping my fingers crossed that it is Melissa, and the privacy part of it has to do with her parents. Maybe? Hopefully? Haha I can’t wait to find out for sure.
CC, February 24, 2009:

The theory is that he does pick melissa but breaks it off & goes back to molly?!?! That is why they shot another ‘after the rose’ special.
JON, February 24, 2009:

In the clip it shows dark hair and mellissa is the one with the darker hair.
Jennifer, February 24, 2009:

I’m not into all these small details, but if I know one thing it’s Melissa. Not Molly. Sure he and Molly are compatible and all but it’s got to be Melissa.
Beth, February 24, 2009:

yes, he choses Melissa but then breaks up with her at the 1st after the rose ceremony.. he is now with Molly
ashley, February 26, 2009:

he breaks up with melissa and goes back to molly
Stace, February 27, 2009:

This is what I think. He proposes to Melissa but calls it off so he can ask Melissa’s parents for PERMISSION to marry their daughter.
karly, February 27, 2009:

i read on a website that he picks melissa and then dumps her on the show for molly. if that is true i will never watch this show again unless she is the next batchlorette even though on the girls tell it all chris asked jillian if she would want to be the next batchlorette and then idk if i would watch it. but melissa def should win she is a better choice for him then molly but i saw in the previews and it looked like ty was having more fun with molly and whoever ty likes the most will probably be the person that jason picks. but melissa should win and btw u cant tell if she won from the moles on her arm thats rediculous!
kip, February 27, 2009:

go melissa! she is way better then molly! and omg can u believe that deanna is actually is goin back and saying that she made a mistake and wants him back!!! it doesnt work that way honey!
Amy, February 28, 2009:

I think all that spoiler stuff is baloney. My guess is that he picks Melissa, and the whole “after the rose thing” is him meeting her parents. Think about it- they are private people… didn’t want their hope invaded… Chris wanted it to be as “intimate” a taping as possible…
No way he goes back and forth as to who he wants. He is 20 times the man of any bachelor thus far and would not do that.
Sheryl, February 28, 2009:

If this scenario of him choosing Melissa first and then dumping her to go with Molly is true—imagine how Molly must feel. (We all know Melissa would be CRUSHED.) But for Molly, she’s gotta feel bitter sweet–like yeah, he picked me, but I was second choice. Whatever! Maybe Molly just wouldn’t leave he and Melissa alone. Molly is definitely my pick, but to be second choice isn’t too great.
mary, March 2, 2009:

If you look at the “proposal pictures” of both melissa and molly, you can see that there are 2 different backgrounds. Melissa’s is more tropical NZ looking, and Molly’s looks more like Seattle (pine trees etc – with the water in the back / Pugent Sound. What if both of the women reject HIM??? Melissa for her old boyfriend, and Molly because she’s just not ready to settle down. Another scenario could be that he re-evaluates after talking to Deanna and brings Jillian back and they have the ATRF ceremony in Seattle. Could be that he sends one of the girls home before TFR and brings Jillian in as the second girl. ABC needs the ratings, and needs to have a successful “Bachelor.” Also, when Jason was talking to Jillian in the coffeeshop to tell her that he needed to know how serious she was and if she was there for him – could have been a discussion of how the story was going to play out – hence, their passionate hot-tub scene in the hot tub – last night before the conclusion of the show. Just my musings……
Michelle, March 2, 2009:

It just showed clips of the episode tonight and neither one of the girls has the light blue dress on. I am going to guess that he doesn’t pick either girl and he picks for tomorrows “after/final rose” We won’t know until tomorrow.
Micheline, March 2, 2009:

I am going to lose my mind if he does not pick Melissa. I am going nuts trying to figure this out!!!
Kay, March 2, 2009:

Anybody heard the rumor that he picks Melissa, but then breaks up with her because Molly is pregnant?
Michelle, March 2, 2009:

I haven’t heard that she is pregnant but i just see him dump Melissa AFRS. Hasn’t really explained why. He said he hasn’t talked with Molly.
Unicorn, March 3, 2009:

I thought Jason is a better man than all of the other bachelors. I thought WRONG! He is the worst one. He breaks off his engagement to Melissa so he can go to Molly. Idiot really… and he still did’nt answer Molly’s question.
rose c, March 8, 2009:

Molly.. why Molly Jason? she is all wrong for you. IN addition to that fact.. she has a very annoying face the eyes (oh my gosh her eyes…popped out and sickening looking…) and her smile… with her bottom lip stuck out… she seems boring.. and just… awkward.. too serious for you, not the right match for you Jason. Jason.. besides the fact that you have made the wrong choice to go with Molly… well actually.. it’s not like you and Molly would last anyways.. I just thought you should know many people that watched your show thinks Molly’s face is JUST simply annoying looking!!!! AAAhh!!! You guys would have such annoying looking babies. just like Molly’s face.
tino, March 11, 2009:

Jason, you just missed your luck by letting melissa go. she was so perfect for you..now i really don’t think you’ll ever find the right girl for you..
tabby, March 20, 2009:

jason, i hope you are reading this. you missed your calling for the stupid mens list. melissa was the right choice for you. everyone has problems in relationships. but you work together to work them out. hope you dont change your mind again. after dumping melissa on national tv, she should laugh in your face on nationnal tv. i know i would!!!!!!!
moxy, March 23, 2009:

it would be nice if everyone looked at some of the important facts.
jason, melissa and exec. producer fleiss all have said that jason and melissa were broken up prior to the show AFTR. so it stands to reason that they were and the whole exchange between melissa and jason was a play, not real. also jason has said he did not want to do the breakup on tv, well what he really meant was that he did not want to do a breakup that was a staged event. Just realize that it was only about ratings and Jason was forced to do it publicly on tv even though it was already over. Melissa put on an academy award performance and knew she would get huge amount of sympathy to launch into what she wanted along to be in the entertainment field.
also one has to wonder why melissa would come on tv to breakup when it was already done. could it be fame, public sympathy so that she could jump into something like DWTS? You should be aware that melissa has been on four reality shows in about two years…two seasons of the reality show about the dallas cowboys cheerleaders, the bachelor and now DWTS. I don’t think we should be saying poor melissa. Plus in a entertainment magazine today she revealed that her career goal is to be an entertainment news correspondent…not a first grade teacher, which is something she deceived Jason on during the bachelor show. So it is now it really appears that she is a woman on it looking for fame.
paul Gupure, April 5, 2009:

jason why did you do that honestly,you should have thought about it before appearing in public with such a dehumanising activity. you embarassed Mellissa on top of the heartbreak.you might be ribght in your own sense but, you will never be right in the generality of the majority of the viewers who highly respected you and this will be turned to furry and hurt, though you will pretend you dont mind deep down you if you have conscience you know you acted very wrongly.Noone can judge you except God but i feel envious for what you did. I can see problems ahead of you although I am wishing you all the luck and happiness that there is.You disappointed me Jason, I dont mind your choice, I would have embraced anything from you but the way you did it obviously puts viewers on Mellissa,s side and why you did that to all of us remains the question. You should have avoided this Jason!